
These muffins freeze well and make a great, fast breakfast.
English muffins are neither English nor muffins, but that won’t matter to your family when you serve them fresh off the griddle! Your loved ones will be wowed by the nooks and crannies, but they won’t miss the dough conditioners and preservatives found in the commercial version. (Click here to read more about bread additives.)
I’ve been making English muffins a few years, but recently stumbled upon Alton Brown’s Food Network recipe and embarked upon a voyage of discovery. Here’s the thing, I will often read four or five recipes on the ‘net, then return to a circa 1970 Rodale book or a more recent Cooking Light volume for guidance. My recipes are often an amalgamation of this process. But there was something about Alton Brown’s recipe that made me want to prepare it the moment I read it. And I’m glad I did, because his version produces top quality fork-split muffins. In that regard, it is far better than the recipe I have been using. If, however, you don’t have English muffin rings, and aren’t looking to invest in a half dozen (which, if purchased online, will run you about $16, shipped) there’s little point in mixing the batter. Trust one who has tried coffee cans, tuna cans, homemade aluminum foil rings and, yes, bona fide English muffin rings: you need the real deal.
These top two recipes will turn out respectable muffins without the special muffin rings or the #20 ice cream scoop called for in Brown’s recipe. The first recipe is from Nitty Gritty Cookbooks’ 1975 Bread Baking written by Lou Pappas. The second is my adaptation.
Sourdough English Muffins
Yield: 2 dozen muffins
Ingredients
1 cup sourdough starter (here’s my favorite starter recipe)
2 cups milk
4 ½ cups all-purpose flour
2 TBS sugar
1 1/2 tsp salt
1 tsp soda
cornmeal
Directions
Combine starter, milk and 4 cups of flour in a large mixing bowl; mix well. Cover with a dish towel and let stand at room temperature 8 hours or overnight. Mix remaining ½ cup flour with sugar, salt and soda; sprinkle over dough and mix well. Turn dough out onto a floured board and knead a few minutes or until no longer sticky. Roll out dough ¾ inch thick and cut into rounds. Sprinkle a jelly roll pan with cornmeal; set muffins on top, leaving at least ½ inch between. Dust tops with cornmeal; cover and let rise in a warm place until doubled. Cook on a griddle set to 275 degrees for 8-10 minutes per side. Split and toast.

Who wants a fresh muffin?
My Adaptation
Yield: 2 dozen muffins
For efficiency’s sake, I double this recipe and freeze muffins we will not consume within a few days. (which sounds slightly noble until you learn that we usually stand over the griddle, grabbing just-cooked muffins and slathering same with better butter.
Ingredients
1 cup sourdough starter (again, here’s my favorite starter recipe
2 cups milk
3 cups unbleached white flour
1 cup whole wheat flour
3 TBS vinegar (my homemade vinegar recipe )
1 1/2 TBS sugar
1 1/4 tsp salt
1 ½ tsp soda
masa harina
Directions are the same as above
Notes: I habitually reduce sugar and salt in recipes, figuring that we can do without some of each. This habit has never produced a bad result. I also habitually substitute a portion of white flour with whole wheat to boost nutrition. Care must be used here, as whole wheat is a far heavier flour, thus too much will change the texture of your finished product. As a rule of thumb, I use between 30 and 50% whole wheat flour in a given recipe. I routinely substitute masa harina for cornmeal when used as a coating in bread recipes: masa is finer, and adds a pleasing flavor to bread. Also, I find, masa purchased in the Hispanic aisle of my local grocer is a fraction of the cost of cornmeal. I have been experimenting with adding vinegar to sourdough bread as a way to boost the tang. I lifted the idea right off the ingredients label of a particularly tangy sourdough bread made by a regional organic bakery. This time I used 3 TBS of my homemade sage and garlic flavored vinegar. I add more baking soda for the same reason I add vinegar.

Brown's version served with homemade apple butter & better butter
Yield: 8 to 10 muffins
Ingredients
1/2 cup non-fat powdered milk
1 tablespoon sugar
1 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon shortening (OK, I admit it: I used olive oil)
1 cup hot water
1 envelope dry yeast
1/8 teaspoon sugar

Brown's version produces superior nooks and crannies
1/3 cup warm water
2 cups all-purpose flour, sifted
Non-stick vegetable spray (I used olive oil here too)
Special equipment: electric griddle, 3-inch metal rings, see Alton’s Note*
Directions
Combine powdered milk, 1 TBS sugar, 1/2 tsp salt, shortening, and hot water; stir until sugar and salt dissolve fully; cool. Combine yeast and 1/8 tsp sugar with 1/3 cup warm water, allow to rest until yeast has dissolved. Add yeast mixture to dry milk mixture. Sift in the flour and beat thoroughly; cover with dish towel and let rest 30 minutes in a warm spot.
Add remaining 1/2 tsp salt to mixture and beat thoroughly. Place metal rings onto the griddle and coat lightly with vegetable spray. Place a ¼ cup batter into each ring. Cover with a pot lid or jelly roll pan; cook on 300 degree griddle for 5-6 minutes. Uncover; flip rings; replace cover. Cook another 5-6 minutes or until golden brown. Place on a cooling rack, remove rings and let cool. Split with fork and serve.
*Alton’s Note: Small tuna cans with tops and bottoms removed work well for metal rings.
Esmaa’s Note: Forget about the tuna cans. For one thing, commercial food cans are now usually lined with plastic, which leaches BPA (read more about associated health risks here.) Then there’s the issue that newfangled rounded edge can bottoms no longer lend themselves to the can opener process as did the water chestnut can (pictured) that I’ve been using as a biscuit cutter for nigh onto 30 years. Also, forget making the tin foil rounds as suggested by a commenter on Mr. Brown’s recipe page unless you don’t mind the trouble to create a new form for each muffin. At least I couldn’t remove the muffin without destroying the foil round.

Brown's version ready to come off the griddle